BetaHCF Case Studies Library is in beta. We're still adding campaigns and fixing things.
HCF Case Studies Library

← All campaigns · Open in the library

wuwm.com

Milwaukee co-sleeping campaign (knife in bed)

Also: Your baby sleeping next to you can be just as dangerous

“Your baby sleeping next to you can be just as dangerous.”

November 2011 posters and PSAs showing a baby in an adult bed beside a large butcher knife (one version with a white baby, one with a Black baby), with a phone number for a free portable crib. Health Commissioner Bevan Baker defended the shock approach given the city's infant death rate; critics said it shamed bed-sharing parents and ignored wider causes.

Years
2011–now
Country
United States
Topic
Infant sleep
Asks people to
Stop
Strategy
Fear appeal
Channel
OutdoorTV
Audience
Parents
Milwaukee parents, especially Black families

Evidence

NoneUnknown

No published evaluation found. A 2013 local report said deaths from unsafe sleep stayed constant (WUWM). Peacock et al. found three quarters of 13 US city safe sleep campaigns used fear appeals, 60% of those with guilt or blame, and none had published evaluations.

Sponsor (who paid)

  • City of Milwaukee Health Department State local government

Credits (who made it)

Not recorded yet.

Related campaigns

Sources

  1. Milwaukee hopes babies and butcher knives wake parents up to dangers of co-sleeping (ABC News, Nov 2011) news · 2011
  2. Milwaukee co-sleeping ad stirs nationwide debate (Wisconsin Health News) news · 2011
  3. Co-sleeping deaths persist in Milwaukee (WUWM, 2013) news · 2013
  4. Peacock NR et al. Qualitative analysis of infant safe sleep public campaign messaging. Health Promot Pract 2017 reference · 2017 · DOI 10.1177/1524839917690339 · PMID 29161896

Research notes

Created 2026-10-23 from the sleep campaign literature search (PubMed and web search; OpenAlex was unreachable), see docs/sleep-campaigns-literature.md. Findings are paraphrased from abstracts, not full texts; official URLs come from search results and were not opened. Good test case for the boomerang/blame question. Agency credit not found. URL seen in WebSearch results;

Record cases/milwaukee-co-sleeping-campaign.json, updated 2026-10-23· Link to this campaign